Prince William County, Virginia
Board of County Supervisors
John T. Stirrup
Gainesville District Supervisor

Sudley North Government Center
7873 Ashton Avenue
Manassas, Virginia 20109
Office: (703) 792-6195     
Fax: (703) 792-7664
Email: Gainesville@pwcgov.org

    

 

                                   

Homepage

Immigration

Transmission Lines

My Biography

Contact Us

Transportation

Land Use

Taxes

Newsletter

Events

Links

New Residents

Town Hall Meetings

Who's My Legislator

Schools

Public Safety

Volunteer

Community Development

 

Transmission Lines

(Some of the files on this page are very large and may not download immediately)

What's New

There have been some new developments in the transmission line issue. In a report filed July 28, 2008, State Corporation Commission (SCC) Hearing Examiner Alexander Skirpan held that construction of the transmission line proposed by Dominion Virginia Power is necessary to serve northern Virginia and to resolve overloads projected to occur in 2011. The report recommends the Commission grant approval for the applicants, Dominion Virginia Power, to construct the proposed Meadow Brook – Loudoun 500 kV transmission line within existing company owned right-of-way (ROW) for the entire path in Virginia; the Dominion segment is generally known as the proposed “Southern” Route.

Judge Skirpan based his decision of need on the following findings:

1.        The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) transmission reliability planning standards are mandatory and PJM Interconnection (a regional electrical transmission organization) and Dominion properly applied the standards.
2.        The Applicants load forecast assumptions that demand-side management remain at current levels are reasonable.
3.        Applicants' assumptions regarding future generation "are consistent with federally-mandated functional separation of transmission and generation, and PJM's general lack of authority to cause [new] generation to be constructed." Those assumptions "produce less reliable load-flow results the farther projections are made into the planning horizon."
4.        The Applicants' projected load-flow result for 2011 and 2102 support need to address NERC violations.
5.        The Amos - Kemptown 765 kV line is a "viable alternative" but the Meadowbrook - Loudoun line is "the best alternative to meet the need demonstrated in these proceedings" because it will be in service in 2011, unlike Amos - Kemptown, and Amos - Kemptown is more "uncertain" since it is "further behind in the regulatory queue."
6.        SCC approval should be conditioned on approval of the West Virginia and Pennsylvania segments of the line being approved. Judge Skirpan recommends the Amos – Kemptown line as the better alternative if the Pennsylvania or West Virginia segment is not approved.

Skirpan recommends that the PJM generation assumptions be accepted for transmission planning purposes. Judge Skirpan concludes the proposed Southern Route makes better use of existing right-of-way and would have less impact on historic and cultural assets.

The report serves as a recommendation to the SCC which makes the final decision. “The Commissioners may accept, modify, or reject the examiner's recommendations." The entire report is available on the SCC's case information website at:
http://www.scc.virginia.gov/case/index.aspx. Click on “docket search” and then on “recent actions.” The report is on the site in 4 parts.

At this time, we do not know when the Commissioners will make their decision. Contact information is available for the SCC on their website State Corporation Commission. We will make sure to keep you posted on any up-dated information we receive. Please feel free to contact my office by phone at (703) 792-6195 or my email
Gainesville@pwcgov.org.

Overview of the Issue

Dominion Power has proposed to build a 500kV transmission line from the Meadow Brook substation in Frederick County to the Loudoun County substation.  The proposed transmission line would consist of towers averaging 125 to 150 feet in height, spaced approximately 1000 feet apart, with a right-of-way width of 150 feet.   The original proposed alignment directly affects the following areas of the Gainesville District: areas north of Route 29, Antioch Road, the Silver Lake property, the Dominion Valley Community and properties along Route 15 north of Route 234.  The links below will show the original proposed alignments, as well as the new alternative routes recently proposed.

Full Route Map

Map 7 (Prince William County)

Map 8 (Prince William County)

New Alternatives

In conjunction with the proposed transmission lines, PJM Interconnection, a regional transmission organization of which Dominion is a member, has applied for a NIETC designation.  Known as the Allegheny Mountain NIETC,, it includes 15 Counties in Virginia.  If approved by the Department of Energy, Dominion would be able to invoke Federal eminent domain powers, if SCC denies Dominions application or does not act within one year of the filing date.

On February 13, 2007, Dominion Power issued a press release announcing that they had chosen a preferred route for the Meadow Brook to Loudoun Substation transmission line.  This alignment is the "Existing Corridor Alternative" which is approximately 68 miles long.  While this alignment is significantly different from the original proposed alignment, the preferred alignment will still affect large portions of Prince William County including the Linton Hall Corridor, the Manassas Battlefield, Sudley Park and areas along Pageland Lane and Sanders Lane.  Dominion has provided a detailed map of the preferred alignment.  (You will have to zoom in to see the route, which is in light blue).  Even though Dominion has determined their preferred route, any of the alternatives could be selected by the SCC.  What has not changed are my concerns regarding the need for a new transmission line.  Dominion has yet to demonstrate that all other possible measures, short of the construction of a new transmission line, have been exhausted.  Measures such as demand response, would lower the demand for power throughout the region and could have a significant impact on the need for the new transmission lines.

What Your Elected Officials Are Doing

My office has been working closely with Congressman Davis, Congressman Wolf, State Senator Colgan, Delegate Marshall as well as representatives of neighboring jurisdictions, and local groups.  We have been coordinating our efforts in order to attain the greatest effect.  Below is a brief history of actions taken by me, the Prince William Board of County Supervisors and other elected officials.

On December 5, 2006, Dominion Power came before the Board of County Supervisors.  In that meeting, Dominion Power committed to responding to several questions I had in writing so that I could distribute the answers to residents who were interested in the topic.  After numerous requests, Dominion has finally sent a response to my questions.

On December 12, 2006, the Prince William Board of County Supervisors (BOCS) unanimously passed a resolution opposing the transmission lines and the designation of a NIET corridor.  As of February 2007, eight other jurisdictions and organizations have passed similar resolutions, with more expected to do so in the future. 

On January 24, 2007 I held an Emergency Town Hall Meeting on the proposed transmission lines at Battlefield High School.  Approximately 800 people attended the meeting, which was intended to educate people on the issue and let people know what they can do to help.  Congressman Davis, Congressman Wolf, and Delegate Marshall attended and spoke on their individual efforts on this issue.  I have included the presentation slides given at this meeting.

Senator Colgan, Delegate Marshall and other legislators in the Northern Virginia region have tried to address the transmission lines during the current legislative session.  Numerous bills were submitted to the House and the Senate for consideration.  The 2007 Legislative session is now over and three bills concerning transmission lines were sent to the Governor for ratification.  The three bills are:  

1.     Delegate Bob Marshall's HB 3031, which lets a locality set the conditions for the placement of overhead electric power transmission lines in conformity to the comprehensive plan of the locality.

2.     Delegate Timothy Hugo’s HB 2708, requires service providers to purchase excess electricity generated by a customer-generator upon request of the customer-generator. 

3.     Senator Colgan’s SB 1362, requires the State Corporation Commission to review the monetary effect the facility will have on the value of land and structures along a proposed corridor, the applicant’s assessment of need, load flow analysis and method of installation.  In addition, the bill requires a GIS map be made publicly available on the applicant’s website, and requires the Joint Commission on Technology and Science to convene a workgroup to develop recommendations as to the factors that should be considered by the State Corporation Commission in reviewing applications for the construction of electrical utility facilities.

On February 5, 2007, Congressman Wolf and Congressman Davis introduced their cosponsored bill (H.R.829) before Congress, which if approved, will repeal the section of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 that authorized the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) to designate National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors (NIETC) and/or grant permits for projects in those corridors.  Progress of the bill can be tracked on the Library of Congress website.  From the main page you can search for the bill by number (H.R. 829) or by the bill's sponsors. 

Several residents have contacted our office regarding the possible health effects of living near transmission lines.  Congressman Wolf has sent our office literature from the Library of Congress.  This information can be viewed on the internet through the following links:

http://health.nih.gov/result.asp?disease_id=229&terms=electromagnetic

http://www.niehs.nih.gov/external/faq/pwrlines.htm

http://www.niehs.nih.gov/external/faq/substation.htm

http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/Risk/magnetic-fields

http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/emf/

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/electromagneticfields.html

http://www.who.int/peh-emf/en/

http://www.mcw.edu/gcrc/cop/powerlines-cancer-FAQ/toc.html

http://www.niehs.nih.gov/emfrapid/

www.epri.com/emf/294825_NIEHSreport1999.pdf

http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2004/112-6/ss.html

Energy Efficiency and Load Management:
On April, 10, 2007 I offered a
resolution, which was adopted by the Board of County Supervisors (BOCS).  This resolution is the first step toward addressing demand-side management and load management in Prince William County.  According to the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), Virginia ranks last in the United States in energy efficiency.  Currently, Dominion Power has no load management program.  I would encourage everyone to contact Dominion and request that they begin a program.  NOVEC has a load management program, which includes various incentives to encourage participation.  NOVEC has provided a brochure to my office explaining the program and its benefits.  I have enrolled in the program and I would encourage all who are served by NOVEC to do so as well.  If every American home replaced just one light bulb with an ENERGY STAR, we would save enough energy to light more than 2.5 million homes for a year and prevent greenhouse gases equivalent to the emissions of nearly 800,000 cars.  More tips on energy efficiency is available at the ENERGY STAR website.  

Dominion Power Filing:
On Thursday, April 19, 2007, Dominion Power filed their application for the proposed 500 kilovolt (500kV) transmission line.  Details of the filing and an explanation of the SCC process are posted on
Dominion Power's website .  Further information on the filing should also be posted on the SCC website soon.  

The SCC has not yet issued the scheduling order for this case.  Representatives of the SCC have said that correspondence on this case should be held until appropriate email addresses and Post Offfice box can be set up.  I will announce this information as soon as it becomes available.

Department of Energy Public Hearing:
The Department of Energy (DOE) finalized the Mid-Atlantic Area National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor (NIETC) by announcing yesterday that it was giving power companies new leverage to force landowners to permit the installation of electric transmission lines by approving the federal designation for a Mid-Atlantic Area National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor (NIETC). The designation gives power companies the right to go over the heads of local officials and overturn the action of state
regulators in determining where power lines may be constructed.

This corridor designation affects all of Prince William County and will be in effect for twelve years. Please feel free to view the 136 page
DOE report.

This report states on page 131 that all applications for rehearing must be received within 30 days. Any resident who filed comments with DOE can consider applying for a rehearing (see page 130 for clarity).

What Can You Do Now?

1.     There are several things every resident can do which will help our efforts.  I have included a contact list of your elected officials.  I encourage you to contact your elected officials and let them know how you feel on this issue.  In particular, I would recommend that you contact Governor Tim Kaine as he is instrumental in setting energy policy for the State of Virginia.  Governor Kaine's contact information is included in the link above.  Also, contact the SCC and the Honorable Samuel Bodman, Secretary of the U.S. Department of Energy who will oversee PJM’s request for a National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor designation.  Correspondence to Mr. Bodman should be directed to:


The Honorable Samuel Bodman
Secretary, U.S. Department of Energy
1000 Independence Ave.
Washington , DC 20585

epact1221@hq.doe.gov
The.Secretary@hq.doe.gov
(800) 342-5363

2.     Stay informed.  I am periodically sending information to everyone who has requested updates on the issue.  If you would like to be included, please email Gainesville@pwcgov.org and ask to be added to the distribution list.  In addition to my website, several other organizations are following this issue.  I have included links to different websites below:

www.wewontglow.com

www.pwconserve.org/issues/landuseplanning/powerline/index.htm

www.whosedominion.org

3.     Attend public meetings and rallies. 

4.     Finally, spread the word.  Try to get at least five family members or friends to contact their elected officials. There is strength in numbers.


©2005 Gainesville District Supervisor. All rights reserved.
Web Hosting by:
VASI (Virginia Sy
stems, Inc.) and InterPublishing Group